“Where did you go to high school?”-a guide for those new to St. Louis


“Nashville Community High School,” I respond to quizzical looking faces.  “Oh, you’re from Tennessee, you don’t have an accent at all.”  “No, Nashville, IL, it’s a small town about an hour east of St. Louis.”   *Blank stare* “Oh.”

It’s been 8 years since I first started working in St. Louis and I’m pretty certain I’ve had this conversation thousands of times.  I had no idea what was going on, how strange is it that people are asking me this when obviously it had been years since I went to high school.  Finally a native of the city informed me that they are really asking me what part of town I grew up in, what my background is, what kind of family I came from, what type of means I have.  WOW, that’s a loaded question.  I still answer this question in the same way most of the time.

I somehow feel it would not be appropriate for me to answer with “Well, I grew up in a really small farming town in Southern Illinois, my parents were very involved, we were middle class with a nice four bedroom house, big back yard, sports were really important, so were academics, we went to church on Sundays, my dad was a teacher, it wasn’t a very diverse community but it wasn’t backwards.”  Despite the fact that this is what they are asking for I don’t think it would go over very well, or maybe it would.  Often my answer is a simple “I’m not origianlly from St. Louis.”

Has anyone who is not from St. Louis found a good way to navigate this question?  Any advice from those who often find they are askers of this question?

Brought to you by: Mills Properties
Photo Courtesy of: Town Maps USA

About Melissa Jensen

Melissa is a native of the Greater St. Louis region. She is addicted to anything Google, and cannot understand why motion activated paper towel dispensers never see her hands.

, , , , , , , ,

  • Jessica

    I always just start off by saying, I’m from the Illinois side, then you get either an eye roll(those St. Louisans who fear “the other side of the river”) or “Oh really, where?”, in which case you can explain: “a small town near ____ of about x number of people.” I’m from Belleville so people generally recognize that one and then ask me if I know so and so. In your case I guess it would be less likely someone would know someone from there, but if you throw in the near(insert larger nearby town), maybe then they would ask you if you know someone from that town?

  • http://mbrewergroup.com mbrewer

    I really don’t get the whole “where did you go to high school conversation.” Seems juvenile to me in many ways. I relocated from the likes of San Francisco, Seattle and Portland where the conversations were more along the lines of “what crazy awesome and amazing thing did you do this weekend.” Or, “what cause are you donating your time to this month.” Compelling stuff with a great deal of substance and zeal.

    I guess that is what you get from getting out and experiencing the great big world outside of STL. Maybe I will understand it some day…

    • Melissa Jerashen

      I agree that it seems juvenile it also strikes me as very closed minded and judgemental, where I went to high school 13 years ago has very little bearing on who I am or where I am today. It will matter even less in 20 years when I’m certain I will still be getting asked.

  • F St. Louis

    While it’s rude to answer a question with a question, you can respond with one of the following:

    “Why would anyone ask such a question?” 
    “I grew up near the Atlantic Ocean.  Have you ever seen the Atlantic Ocean?”